Všechna hlášení
Hlášení Tiến Lên
#73327: "Implement Tien Len "real" scoring"
implemented: Tento návrh byl implementován
1
Čeho se toto hlášení týká?
Co se stalo? Prosím vyberte níže
Podnět: podle mého názoru by následující významně vylepšilo hru
Detailní popis
-
• Prosím popiš svůj návrh přesně a konzistentně, aby bylo snadné pochopit, co máš na mysli.
All Tien Lien vietnamese app add another layer of scoring which greatly enhances the game tension (by using penalties for unused 2s, for unplayed hand, for getting bombed,...), it would greatly benefit to this implementation. I believe this is the real "tien len" .
(there's also several great/popular scoring variants , but that's not the request here) • Jaký prohlížeč používáte?
Google Chrome v106
Historie hlášení
10. Oct 2022 22:43 • Hellkite19 • Vývojáři souhlasí, že je to dobrý nápad, a mají v úmyslu na tom pracovat:
Shobu, the original Tien Len played in Vietnam just has basic rules to appeal to the casual Vietnamese citizens when they play with their friends and family during the Tet holiday.
The extra scoring is for players wanting to play more competitively hence why you see it in the Vietnamese apps. I do agree on adding these scoring variations for more complex gameplay. I will try to get to this after knocking out the higher priority bugs in the game.
The extra scoring is for players wanting to play more competitively hence why you see it in the Vietnamese apps. I do agree on adding these scoring variations for more complex gameplay. I will try to get to this after knocking out the higher priority bugs in the game.
11. Oct 2022 23:06 • Shobu • Vývojáři souhlasí, že je to dobrý nápad, a mají v úmyslu na tom pracovat:
Yes those advanced rules should only be programmed once the main program is finished.
I understand there's not a real Tien Len ruleset (you even have Tien Len in North Vietnam which even have bigger differences), but those advanced rules really makes the game better, and more fun :)
I understand there's not a real Tien Len ruleset (you even have Tien Len in North Vietnam which even have bigger differences), but those advanced rules really makes the game better, and more fun :)
17. Oct 2022 19:58 • Hellkite19 • Vývojáři souhlasí, že je to dobrý nápad, a mají v úmyslu na tom pracovat:
Can you list all of the scoring differences you seen in other Tien Len apps? I am not sure how many differences there are for me to program in the game.
17. Oct 2022 22:14 • Shobu • Vývojáři souhlasí, že je to dobrý nápad, a mají v úmyslu na tom pracovat:
ok will do it, need to cross check my reference sources
9. Nov 2022 22:10 • Shobu • Vývojáři souhlasí, že je to dobrý nápad, a mají v úmyslu na tom pracovat:
===Penalties=== (as implemented on "Tien Len Choi Nhanh" app)
When a game end, player who still have 2 or special card sets in their hands is penalized. The penalty for:
- a black 2 is 1point
- a red 2, or 3 consecutive pair or a quadruple s is 2pts,
- and the penalty 4 consecutive pairs is 4pts.
If a player has finished his hand while another player (P2) still have 13cards in hands, this player P2 is expelled ("locked") from the current hand, and get a -2 penalty
When a game end, player who still have 2 or special card sets in their hands is penalized. The penalty for:
- a black 2 is 1point
- a red 2, or 3 consecutive pair or a quadruple s is 2pts,
- and the penalty 4 consecutive pairs is 4pts.
If a player has finished his hand while another player (P2) still have 13cards in hands, this player P2 is expelled ("locked") from the current hand, and get a -2 penalty
9. Nov 2022 22:14 • Shobu • Vývojáři souhlasí, že je to dobrý nápad, a mají v úmyslu na tom pracovat:
There's also a penalty when your 2 get bombed ("chopped"), but i need to search detail as penalties can be cumulated (if somebody bomb a triplepair with a quad).
There's also auto-win condition, every app has them but it feel a bit weird and i'm not 100% sure about them:
"Certain hands are recognized as "auto win" hands. Games with these hands are not played. The owner of the special hand wins the game. "
Hand containing 6 pairs.
Hand containing 5 consecutive pairs.
Hand containing 4 deuces.
Dragon series, hand containing a series of 13 cards (series of 12 and a deuce).
Partial dragon series, hand containing a series of 12 cards.
13 black (or red) cards.
12 black (or red) cards.
There's also auto-win condition, every app has them but it feel a bit weird and i'm not 100% sure about them:
"Certain hands are recognized as "auto win" hands. Games with these hands are not played. The owner of the special hand wins the game. "
Hand containing 6 pairs.
Hand containing 5 consecutive pairs.
Hand containing 4 deuces.
Dragon series, hand containing a series of 13 cards (series of 12 and a deuce).
Partial dragon series, hand containing a series of 12 cards.
13 black (or red) cards.
12 black (or red) cards.
10. Nov 2022 03:34 • Hellkite19 • Vývojáři souhlasí, že je to dobrý nápad, a mají v úmyslu na tom pracovat:
Can you explain in more detail what being locked means? I still don't quite understand. Also there is a lot of scoring differences in this report to easily keep track on what needs to be done. Can you make new separate reports for game penalties and auto wins since they do different things with points. I will close this report when the new reports are made.
14. Nov 2022 11:06 • Shobu • Vývojáři souhlasí, že je to dobrý nápad, a mají v úmyslu na tom pracovat:
Ok will make separate reports
17. Nov 2022 23:55 • Hellkite19 • Vývojáři si myslí, že to není dobrý nápad nebo poměr cena/výhody je příliš vysoký:
Specific reports have been made from the information here so I am closing this report.
Doplňte tuto zprávu
Prosím přidej sem cokoli, co by mohlo být relevantní pro reprodukci této chyby nebo pochopení tvého návrhu:
- ID dalšího stolu / ID tahu
- Byla chyba odstraněna stisknutím F5?
- Objevila se tato chyba častěji? Pokaždé? Náhodně?
- Pokud máš snímek obrazvky zobrazující tuto chybu (doporučujeme!), můžeš použít Imgur.com pro nahrání obrázku a pak odkaz na tento obrázek na Imguru zkopírovat a vložit sem.
