Všechna hlášení
Hlášení Dice Hospital: ER – Emergency Roll
#80142: " Epidemiologist bonus card - continuous sequence of patients valued 1-6"
fixed: Chyba byla odstraněna
30
Čeho se toto hlášení týká?
Co se stalo? Prosím vyberte níže
Pravidla: pravidla hry nebyla dodržena
Detailní popis
-
• Která část pravidel nebyla dodržena adaptací hry na BGA
Epidemiologist bonus card - continuous sequence of patients valued 1-6
didn't count one of my 3 sequence, see the picture below.
Thank you for the adaptation <3 -
• Je vidět porušení pravidel na záznamu hry? Pokud ano, ve kterém tahu?
end game scoring • Jaký prohlížeč používáte?
Mozilla v5
Historie hlášení
29. Jan 2023 20:22 • Grintus • Chyba zatím nebyla vývojáři reprodukována:
Hello there,
I got the same issue today. Had 3 "streets" and system counted only 1. If I would guess it is because during gameplay the routes change and won't get corrected.
Thank you!
imgur.com/a/bXTAPY4
I got the same issue today. Had 3 "streets" and system counted only 1. If I would guess it is because during gameplay the routes change and won't get corrected.
Thank you!
imgur.com/a/bXTAPY4
30. Jan 2023 07:28 • firgon • Vývojáři požadují další informace k reprodukování chyby:
Hi Grintus_real, i'm sorry i don't understand, for me you have 2 paths and the system counts 2 (in light blue) because you can't coun't a room twice.
30. Jan 2023 07:29 • firgon • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
Oh sorry, you are right, there are 3!!! so maybe the system is as dumb as me :D
30. Jan 2023 07:32 • firgon • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
Ok thank you both, it appear that the system is wrong when the path are really close and could be misscount by counting room twice but, you're both right, each time there is a way to count more points by choosing better your path. I will try to improve that
2. Feb 2023 00:24 • Grintus • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
Hi firgon, thank you for the info about the light blue numbers showing the paths. I didn't notice this little detail.
Besides that good job on that implementation of this game. I was eager to play it!
Besides that good job on that implementation of this game. I was eager to play it!
23. Feb 2023 16:40 • NurseB • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
On my final turn it counted -10 points for the epidemiologist of sequence 1-6. In all I should have three but only counted 2, it actually deleted the third one.
12. Mar 2023 22:07 • xelda • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
I had 3 lines of 1-6, but only 2 were counted. No numbers used twice.
Possibly what happened is this:
Sequence scored using the following numbers;
W1, pos 1 (1)
W2, pos 1 (2)
W3, pos 1 (3)
W4, pos 1 (4)
W5, pos 2 (5)
W6, pos 2 (6)
Later i added the more numbers so that the original sequence could start with the same first 4 numbers, but ended with the last 2 numbers going in a different direction
W3, pos 2 (5)
W3, pos 3 (6)
And a new sequence started with 4 different numbers, but ended with the original last 2 numbers
W3, pos 4 (1)
W3, pos 5 (2)
W4, pos 4 (3)
W4, pos 3 (4)
W5, pos 2 (5)
W6, pos 2 (6)
Maybe it is not allowing a re-routing once numbers are used.
Table 356002152
Possibly what happened is this:
Sequence scored using the following numbers;
W1, pos 1 (1)
W2, pos 1 (2)
W3, pos 1 (3)
W4, pos 1 (4)
W5, pos 2 (5)
W6, pos 2 (6)
Later i added the more numbers so that the original sequence could start with the same first 4 numbers, but ended with the last 2 numbers going in a different direction
W3, pos 2 (5)
W3, pos 3 (6)
And a new sequence started with 4 different numbers, but ended with the original last 2 numbers
W3, pos 4 (1)
W3, pos 5 (2)
W4, pos 4 (3)
W4, pos 3 (4)
W5, pos 2 (5)
W6, pos 2 (6)
Maybe it is not allowing a re-routing once numbers are used.
Table 356002152
13. Mar 2023 07:34 • firgon • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
no, path can be re routed, there just is a bug in algorithm :(
12. Apr 2023 03:25 • ComradeExP • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
I had this same bug in a ranked game :(
17. Apr 2023 20:29 • firgon • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
I need more screen capture and game number to better understand this bug. If you upvote this bug, please furnish these informations.
22. Apr 2023 16:55 • vroum999 • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
4. Jul 2023 13:50 • goldlyn • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
Same problem with epidemiologist bonus not being credited. Playing on Edge, windows 11. Apparently, from previous comments, bug has been confirmed.
25. Sep 2023 19:46 • abeard722 • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
Same issue. I have two paths but only one is scoring.
I rerouted my first sequence and that may be why the second one did not score, even though it should.
Table 420558543
I rerouted my first sequence and that may be why the second one did not score, even though it should.
Table 420558543
9. Oct 2023 03:41 • goldlyn • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
This happened to me again. Last play of the game, my move completed 6 in a row. But because the computer is always slow at recording bonus points, it declared my opponent as the winner. But if the computer had recorded my 10 bonus points, it would have shown me as the actual winner.
table #425297186
Move #49
Progression 100%
Playing on windows 11
table #425297186
Move #49
Progression 100%
Playing on windows 11
30. Jan 2024 08:00 • kseap • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
Hello, one of my paths is not scoring during an Arena game. This is the first time this bug has happened to me.
Table 468632197
Sorry, I don't know how to pull the move ID. Please see photo below.
imgur.com/a/fXrPjUu
Table 468632197
Sorry, I don't know how to pull the move ID. Please see photo below.
imgur.com/a/fXrPjUu
21. May 2024 19:51 • squarerootofthree • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
Happened on table 515364265 and move 45.
I don't know if development has been abandoned on this one but since the dev most recently asked for examples, here's this game's sequence: imgur.com/a/ViJzzGi
After move 45 there were two groups of 1–6 for 20 points. My opponent put a final piece down (a red 5 in the 5th ward) and the game decided to switch to the less optimal one group for 10 points.
I understand the algorithm is not optimal but maybe give players a chance to confirm or select a better route?
I don't know if development has been abandoned on this one but since the dev most recently asked for examples, here's this game's sequence: imgur.com/a/ViJzzGi
After move 45 there were two groups of 1–6 for 20 points. My opponent put a final piece down (a red 5 in the 5th ward) and the game decided to switch to the less optimal one group for 10 points.
I understand the algorithm is not optimal but maybe give players a chance to confirm or select a better route?
29. May 2024 19:19 • ellokello • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
Table 518302848: didn't count ANY of the points for me or my opponent. I noticed from early on but thought it would get corrected by the end. Didn't effect the result this time. This epidemiologist card should be removed unless this problem is resolved. I will propose abandoning games in the meantime.
29. May 2024 21:29 • mspider_89 • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
I also came to this same problem on table #516483660
I have two paths that didn't get scored at the end. The weird thing is that initially the first one was showing up on the scoring. It disappeared when I got my second row on move 65
I have two paths that didn't get scored at the end. The weird thing is that initially the first one was showing up on the scoring. It disappeared when I got my second row on move 65
4. Jun 2024 03:59 • Harmon758 • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
I had two possible routes, neither of which counted, in boardgamearena.com/13/dicehospitaler?table=520940556
4. Jun 2024 04:01 • Harmon758 • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
boardgamearena.com/bug?id=103927 and boardgamearena.com/bug?id=104720 seem to be instances of this bug as well.
5. Jun 2024 22:39 • Fiminor • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
boardgamearena.com/3/dicehospitaler?table=519597134 didn't score any epidemiologist points for either me or my opponent
5. Jun 2024 22:48 • Fiminor • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
boardgamearena.com/6/dicehospitaler?table=520875116 and this game
6. Jun 2024 09:03 • firgon • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
Hi everyone. There are two different bugs.
- From beginning, in some case, the 1to6 epidemiology can be buggy. It's not solved.
- Bga is migrating from PHP 7.4 to PHP 8. It seems that migration broke epidemiologist count. I don't know why and I have to make a full check up to understand. but i have not enough time for that now. i just reverted to 7.4 so new games won't be buggy. but it's too late for on going games. Sorry for the inconvenience.
- From beginning, in some case, the 1to6 epidemiology can be buggy. It's not solved.
- Bga is migrating from PHP 7.4 to PHP 8. It seems that migration broke epidemiologist count. I don't know why and I have to make a full check up to understand. but i have not enough time for that now. i just reverted to 7.4 so new games won't be buggy. but it's too late for on going games. Sorry for the inconvenience.
10. Jun 2024 10:55 • Arnott • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
No problem :) Still happening - not scoring at all (I had three that didn't score! luckily it didn't matter)
boardgamearena.com/6/dicehospitaler?table=523442232
boardgamearena.com/6/dicehospitaler?table=523442232
14. Jun 2024 09:17 • Fiminor • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
Game started 11 June - this is still happening. boardgamearena.com/1/dicehospitaler?table=523845379
14. Jun 2024 17:24 • Fiminor • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
and boardgamearena.com/1/dicehospitaler?table=524271424 started 12/06/24
14. Jun 2024 18:11 • Fiminor • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
and boardgamearena.com/1/dicehospitaler?table=524704440 game started 13/06/24.
@firgon Might just be coincidence but this is 3/3 games started since you reverted back, all have this epidemiologist goal.
@firgon Might just be coincidence but this is 3/3 games started since you reverted back, all have this epidemiologist goal.
15. Jun 2024 11:05 • firgon • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
Ok i will investigate : i would need someone to post a NEW bug report from a game still ongoing with the visible bug. Please !
15. Jun 2024 12:06 • firgon • Chyba byla potvrzena vývojáři:
Ok i found one error. Related to the php 8.0 adaptation, so i hope it will be enough to unstuck you all.
It WON'T fix the 'historical' bug about sometimes misscounting when there are several path between 1 and 6.
But it should allow you to have "normal" games with normal epidemiologist count.
Sorry for the inconvenience.
It WON'T fix the 'historical' bug about sometimes misscounting when there are several path between 1 and 6.
But it should allow you to have "normal" games with normal epidemiologist count.
Sorry for the inconvenience.
15. Jun 2024 12:07 • firgon • Chyba byla odstraněna:
I will close this bug report (over voted due to recent problem) please post a new bug report if you find again the "historical bug" i will investigate then.
Doplňte tuto zprávu
Prosím přidej sem cokoli, co by mohlo být relevantní pro reprodukci této chyby nebo pochopení tvého návrhu:
- ID dalšího stolu / ID tahu
- Byla chyba odstraněna stisknutím F5?
- Objevila se tato chyba častěji? Pokaždé? Náhodně?
- Pokud máš snímek obrazvky zobrazující tuto chybu (doporučujeme!), můžeš použít Imgur.com pro nahrání obrázku a pak odkaz na tento obrázek na Imguru zkopírovat a vložit sem.
