Všechna hlášení
Hlášení Spots
#82878: "Dogpile rolled wrong die chose from the buried dice."
fixed: Chyba byla odstraněna
1
Čeho se toto hlášení týká?
Co se stalo? Prosím vyberte níže
Pravidla: pravidla hry nebyla dodržena
Detailní popis
-
• Která část pravidel nebyla dodržena adaptací hry na BGA
I chose the 4 from my buried dice to roll and instead the 2 was rolled and the 4 was left in the buried dice.
-
• Je vidět porušení pravidel na záznamu hry? Pokud ano, ve kterém tahu?
You can probably see me re-roll the 2, but no way to see that I actually chose the 4.
• Jaký prohlížeč používáte?
Google Chrome v110
Historie hlášení
6. Mar 2023 22:02 • Bryant • Chyba zatím nebyla vývojáři reprodukována:
I had this happen on an earlier turn as well, but thought maybe I misclicked. Was very careful choosing the 4.
6. Mar 2023 22:54 • Kayvon • Vývojáři požadují další informace k reprodukování chyby:
Which move number? Once we know the move number and the game has ended, we can repay that move and make the same decisions you did to confirm the behavior.
8. Mar 2023 16:35 • Kayvon • Vývojářům se nepodařilo tuto chybu reprodukovat:
Unfortunately, we haven't received a response with the required information, so I'm going to close the request. If the information is provided later on, we can always reopen this and investigate.
14. Mar 2023 18:38 • squarerootofthree • Vývojářům se nepodařilo tuto chybu reprodukovat:
I had this happen to me on two consecutive selections on table: 356256575, moves 85 and 87. After the first instance I thought maybe I had selected wrong. On the second instance, I was 100% positive I selected the 4 die and it re-rolled the 1 from the buried dice.
I'm select it from the buried dice area, if that makes a difference.
I'm select it from the buried dice area, if that makes a difference.
14. Mar 2023 19:13 • Mogri • Vývojářům se nepodařilo tuto chybu reprodukovat:
Having reviewed the replay of the original table, I can't get move 37 to work unless I select the 2.
sqrt(3): Please update this ticket when your game ends so I can examine your replay.
sqrt(3): Please update this ticket when your game ends so I can examine your replay.
24. Apr 2023 7:57 • Siveran • Vývojářům se nepodařilo tuto chybu reprodukovat:
Table 370266514 / Move 23
There's three interfaces where you can click dice to select them for dogpile: the yard tile, the interface in the middle, and the scoreboard in the right. The yard tile isn't synchronized with the other two for the order of the dice. Clicking the first die in one interface will select the first die in all the interfaces, but that might be a different die!
For example, if you have:
Yard tile: 3 2 1
Play area: 2 1 3
Scoreboard: 2 1 3
Clicking the 1 on the yard tile will select 3 on the other two. If you hit confirm after clicking the 1 in the yard, it'll reroll the 3.
Clicking the 1 on the play area will select 2 on the yard tile and 1 on the scoreboard. If you hit confirm, it'll reroll the 1.
Basically, the yard tile lies!
There's three interfaces where you can click dice to select them for dogpile: the yard tile, the interface in the middle, and the scoreboard in the right. The yard tile isn't synchronized with the other two for the order of the dice. Clicking the first die in one interface will select the first die in all the interfaces, but that might be a different die!
For example, if you have:
Yard tile: 3 2 1
Play area: 2 1 3
Scoreboard: 2 1 3
Clicking the 1 on the yard tile will select 3 on the other two. If you hit confirm after clicking the 1 in the yard, it'll reroll the 3.
Clicking the 1 on the play area will select 2 on the yard tile and 1 on the scoreboard. If you hit confirm, it'll reroll the 1.
Basically, the yard tile lies!
10. May 2023 16:40 • Two-Sheds • Vývojářům se nepodařilo tuto chybu reprodukovat:
There is definitely a bug here, this just happened to me too. Table 374092184, move 165. I had a 1 and a 5 in the yard, I'm certain I selected the 5, but it took the 1 instead.
10. May 2023 16:42 • Two-Sheds • Vývojářům se nepodařilo tuto chybu reprodukovat:
(I clicked on the yard tile, the 5 was the rightmost (second) die there.)
10. May 2023 17:47 • Kayvon • Vývojářům se nepodařilo tuto chybu reprodukovat:
Can you provide a screenshot, table number, and move number? Without those, the best we can tell you is that it works when we test it and we haven't reproduced the problem.
11. May 2023 15:08 • GandalfDG • Vývojářům se nepodařilo tuto chybu reprodukovat:
This has also happened to me multiple times. The first time I assumed it was a misclick but the second time I was sure that I clicked the die with more spots from my yard but found that the 1 was rolled instead.
#375397018
Move #28
#375397018
Move #28
11. May 2023 15:11 • GandalfDG • Vývojářům se nepodařilo tuto chybu reprodukovat:
If I get a chance I will setup a manual game with dogpile enabled and try to get a screen recording of the bug occurring
11. May 2023 15:57 • Two-Sheds • Vývojářům se nepodařilo tuto chybu reprodukovat:
Table 374092184, move 165
11. May 2023 16:01 • Kayvon • Vývojářům se nepodařilo tuto chybu reprodukovat:
We can't analyze a game that's still in progress (probably as a method to prevent cheating), but I can take a look once your game completes. Just let me know when it's done.
A screen recording would be terrific, too. Thanks.
A screen recording would be terrific, too. Thanks.
11. May 2023 16:05 • Kayvon • Vývojářům se nepodařilo tuto chybu reprodukovat:
@Two-Sheds, the replay indicates you did click on the right die, like you said. When I replay your game, I see that the 1 is the right die, not the 5, so that's what it rerolled.
When you replay that move, do you see something different?
When you replay that move, do you see something different?
11. May 2023 16:18 • Two-Sheds • Vývojářům se nepodařilo tuto chybu reprodukovat:
I don't know about the replay, but I"m sure I clicked on the 5 during the game. And lots of other people are reporting this, we can't all be hallucinating. It looks like @Siveran provided a detailed explanation of the problem. Maybe there's some kind of inconsistency in the ordering of the dice in the yard display, versus the data structure in the code?
11. May 2023 16:39 • Mogri • Chyba byla odstraněna:
I've updated the logic for clicking on dice on the yard tile. This should be fixed now.
11. May 2023 16:44 • Two-Sheds • Vývojářům se nepodařilo tuto chybu reprodukovat:
Looks like you found it 😊👍🏻
11. May 2023 17:01 • GandalfDG • Chyba byla odstraněna:
excellent! Thanks for looking into it and making a fix :)
Doplňte tuto zprávu
Prosím přidej sem cokoli, co by mohlo být relevantní pro reprodukci této chyby nebo pochopení tvého návrhu:
- ID dalšího stolu / ID tahu
- Byla chyba odstraněna stisknutím F5?
- Objevila se tato chyba častěji? Pokaždé? Náhodně?
- Pokud máš snímek obrazvky zobrazující tuto chybu (doporučujeme!), můžeš použít Imgur.com pro nahrání obrázku a pak odkaz na tento obrázek na Imguru zkopírovat a vložit sem.
